Technology Addictions and the Link to Substance Abuse

rosslaird's picture

The Problem:

Addiction is a positive urge thwarted by negative circumstances. Almost all habitual substance users are searching for a means of dealing with psychological stress that is usually associated with childhood and adolescent development.

The addict is drawn to a culture which promises to complete the unfinished impulses of childhood and adolescence. The cultures of technology are sufficiently broad as to offer the psychological rewards of all the cultures of substance use combined.

Technologies are cultures and not simply tools. Geeks, gamers, technophobes, phreaks, demosceners, nerds, hackers, cyberathletes, newbies, crackers: these terms and many others describe technological cultures that have evolved within the context of telephone, television, and computer technologies.

Such cultures share both the positive and negative aspects common to cultures in general. Positive benefits include group identity and cohesion, collaborative activity, and interpersonal connection. Negative consequences include potential addiction, isolation, and diversion from self-care and relationships.

Technology addictions obey the same principles as substance addictions; that is to say, technology addictions involve uncompleted impulses and fractured imprinting typically derived from childhood experience (this is not universally the case, but is almost universally the case). The addictive behavior completes, temporarily, unfinished developmental themes. Those themes might be (arbitrarily) grouped under four basic types:

  • Flight response substances (e.g. hallucinogens) allow one to retreat into the imagination;
  • Freeze response substances (e.g. opiates) enable stillness and solace;
  • Orienting response substances (e.g. stimulants) encourage action and exploration;
  • Fight response substances (e.g. alcohol) enable the illusion of empowerment.

The more childhood difficulty an individual experiences, the more likely the individual is to seek multiple substances in adolescence. This is because adolescence is the period of developmental correction and integration, during which earlier imprinting is revisited and reconsidered (instinctively).

As with substance addictions, technology addictions temporarily complete and fulfill fragmented developmental imprinting:

  • Flight response technologies (e.g. fantasy video games and online worlds) allow one to retreat into the imagination;
  • Freeze response technologies (e.g. television) enable stillness and solace;
  • Orienting response technologies (e.g. strategy video games and social networking) stimulate action and exploration;
  • Fight response technologies (e.g. violent video games) enable the illusion of empowerment.

The more childhood difficulty an individual experiences, the more likely the individual is to seek multiple technologies in adolescence. Adolescence begins with the brain pruning stage at roughly age eleven and continues until the end of the twenties. Because this long period of development involves the integration of previous developmental stages, incomplete or fragmented childhood imprinting re-emerges as adolescent psychological difficulty. Addiction is one method of easing the stress of such unfinished imprinting -- by completing it temporarily.

Solutions?

Modern humans have been around for perhaps as long as 100,000 years. We have been using screen-time technologies for about a decade (with the exception of television, which has been part of the Western lifestyle for slightly longer).

We are animals. Our well-being depends upon bodily movement, expression, and integration. This is what both current and ancestral research consistently demonstrates: our relationship with our own bodies is central to every aspect of our development.

Obesity, ADHD, cancer, diabetes, addictions of all kinds, depression, anxiety, eating disorders, trauma: all of these challenges are consistently correlated with diet and exercise. In fact, healthy diet and exercise are the only two factors that are almost always linked to improvement across the domains of health and wellness.

And yet, in Psychology and Counselling we remain seated in chairs, and we seem content to explore insight and the inner life. That's fine; but insight alone cannot heal the fractured nervous system. Only movement and physical challenge can do that. With the average Canadian youth already seated in a chair and watching a screen for more than 40 hours per week, more chair-sitting seems like a poor idea.

The key to health and wellness is dependable adult mentorship. The only way for an adolescent to develop integration, containment, and identity is through mentorship.

The impulse of kids to form groups is healthy. In evolutionary terms, groups of young people seek leadership from adult mentors. In the absence of healthy adult mentors, adolescents form a youth gang, which comes to be led by the adolescent among them who is most aggressive, gregarious, or risk-prone.

The absence of mentorship for adolescents is the most serious problem in our society today. Absence of mentorship is a primary cause of the addictions problem among both youth and adults, the suicidep problem among youth, the homelessness problem in youth and adults, and the depression and anxiety problem of many people.

Technology addictions involve false mentorship.

For more (much more) on this topic, visit the Technology Addictions Presentation page. For practical solutions and ideas, see the mentorship guide.

blog

Why Addictions Treatment Fails

rosslaird's picture

The rates of success for contemporary addictions treatment are miserable. The vast majority of people who undergo it, whether at a treatment center or in the so-called recovery movement — AA, NA and their companion abbreviations — fail to improve (though if they keep trying, their chances of success increase). Those who enroll in a program do about as well as those who do not. Sometimes they do better. In any given attempt, most addicts who try to improve their situation do not achieve success. And within any given year, something like fifty thousand people in North America die of drug and alcohol use. This number does not include deaths from nicotine addiction, which claims the lives of half of all smokers, or from obesity (addiction to unhealthy eating), which will soon be the leading cause of preventable death in North America.

Heroin addiction and harm reduction

rosslaird's picture

Ray Charles — acclaimed as one of the twentieth century’s foundational musicians — died this week. Some of the retrospective news items, on TV and on the web, noted his 20-year battle with heroin addiction. Many people were unaware of this, and were surprised that such a hard core addiction was part of the life of a man who appeared to be so humane, humorous, and self-aware.

But musicians not addicted to heroin were the exception in the age of Ray Charles’ ascension. Almost all the emergent jazz and blues musicians of the fifties — Miles Davis (and most of his band), Bill Evans, Thelonius Monk — were addicted to heroin at one time or another. Evans, perhaps the greatest pianist of the twentieth century, died of heroin and cocaine addiction. Charles managed to catch it earlier, after his arrest at the Boston airport.

Marijuana Wars

rosslaird's picture

The other night, in one of my counselling classes, we had a small discussion about whether marijuana should be legalized. Many people thought so: after all, pot seems basically harmless. Nobody overdoses or gets violent on the stuff. But in…

More marijuana research

rosslaird's picture

I live in Vancouver, where smoking a joint is part of everyday life for almost everybody who owns a mountain bike and an iPod. So my recent posts about the dangers of marijuana are not likely to go down well…

The Great Secret to Recovery from Addictions

rosslaird's picture

For those addicts genuinely seeking a resolution to their struggle, I’ll tell you the great secret up front: find something else to be addicted to, something healthier. That’s all. Addiction is not a light switch, on or off; it’s a…

The Evolution of Addiction

rosslaird's picture

More news this weekend about increasing trends in drug and alcohol use: in Scotland, in Japan, and among Australian kids.

Addiction evolves in societies, particularly among cultures experiencing stress. And it begins developmentally, in families and in the community. But research trends both in substance use are moving away from developmental questions. Researchers are less interested in childhood development than they once were. Genetic and biochemical factors now dominate the research landscape.

A Short Guide to Quitting Smoking

rosslaird's picture

This morning, on Citytv’s Breakfast Television, I spoke with Shane Foxman, host and aspirant non-smoker, about strategies for understanding and dealing with nicotine addiction. We talked about four basic strategies:

  • Find support: someone to talk to, a group of like-minded quitters, friends or family who are capable of empathy, patience, and kindness. Support is the only recovery strategy consistently correlated with success.
  • Understand the emotional function of the addiction. What role does it play in your life? How does it fulfill a particular need (stress management, relaxation, a social lubricant), and how can you satisfy that same need in other ways?
  • Find a substitute addiction, one that’s healthier. I’ve spoken about this elsewhere on my website. Successfully recovered addicts find new obsessions: spirituality or exercise or meditation or kayaking or whatever. Find something to love that gives you the same hit as smoking. Eventually it will give you a better hit. You’ll find it, if only you give yourself the chance.
  • Accept that relapse may be part of your process. Most people relapse multiple times (as many as 10, 12 or more), and it’s healthier to acknowledge the role of relapse than to berate yourself for being weak. Recovery is not about will power but readiness, and sometimes that readiness takes a while to develop. If you’re not quite there, don’t worry about it. Just keep trying. Eventually the momentum of your desire to quit will overcome the inertia of the addiction.

And finally, stay connected. Isolation is the sure route to failure. Shane is organizing a collaborative quitting circle: consider getting involved (send an email to the show if you want to join the group or offer your feedback).

Addiction and Responsibility

rosslaird's picture

For me, one of the most troubling aspects of the addiction conversation is society is the extent to which people wish to assign blame. The user, the family, society: someone must be at fault. This reflects a general tendency toward…

Healing from Addictions

rosslaird's picture

As I’ve been working on the new book, I’ve been making little notes about approaches to recovery and healing: for parents, siblings, spouses. Here are a few:

The various tricks, systems and strategies all distil down to one thing: focus on yourself. You cannot change the habits or behavior of anyone else. If you are a professional counselor or social service worker, focus on empathy and clarity. Understand that the various recovery strategies for substance use (motivational interviewing, medications, cognitive behavioral treatment) are simply means of making contact, nothing more.

If you are the parent of an adult addict, work on your own emotional management — your anger, your disbelief, your fear. Stop lecturing your child about their addiction. Offer them resources — books, counseling fees, a safe place to get away from the clamor and grit of the addiction lifestyle — but offer these as investments, not conditions. Offer them freely, as open-ended gifts, without the requirement that your child redeem such gifts by discontinuing substance use. If your child is actively using, you will lose any negotiation involving abstinence. Accept this.

Understand that the choices your child is making are beyond their conscious ability to manage. Addiction hijacks the personality (though not the spirit). Express your love, ask how you can help, and acknowledge that you cannot make your child stop using. If you try hard enough to make them stop, you will lose them (though teenagers are a special case, and require special care; the book devotes a chapter to them). As a parent, your task has always been to create and sustain the safe harbor. Keep doing this, and wait for the time that you may be needed.

If you are a spouse, take your partner for a walk — along the beach, in the morning, making it plain beforehand that you have important business to discuss. Ask them to simply listen. Share your feelings, your fears, your struggle. Do this succinctly, in no more than a few minutes, and conclude by asking for the one thing you need. Maybe it’s couples counseling, or treatment for your spouse, or perhaps only a willingness to try. Whatever it is, make a firm deadline by which something must be done. (A week? A month? Certainly not more than a season).

Make it clear what you will do if the deadline is not met: go for counseling on your own, for example (more drastic action, like leaving the relationship, is generally unwise unless several authentic attempts at healing have already been tried). Be prepared to follow through: bluffing may work in poker, but not in addictions. You can’t effectively demand that your spouse stop using, but you can give them a fixed period in which to choose.

If you are addicted — to any one of the infinite number of substances and behaviors available in the modern world — start to pay attention to the corrosiveness of your addictive experiences. Enter into the labyrinth of your emotional life.

Call someone who loves you. Say that you’re in trouble, that you need support. Someone to listen. Forget the history for now — just for today — and ask them to do the same. Stop reading and do it now.

(To be notified when the new book is available, sign up for the newsletter.)